After that, the televisionshow buffy, the vampire slayer followed many of the traditional vampire rules but created vampire protagonists. Smith says one reason the twilight series of books and movies is so. But edward can no longer safely live in the same town as bella. Comparison between dracula by bram stroker and twilight by stephen meyeres 975 words 4 pages the legend of the vampire has emerged countless times within human imagination over the past few centuries. Evil has long been expressed through movies and books throughout history. But that doesnt mean that they dont have value, and it certainly doesnt mean that other people shouldnt be able to enjoy them. The first book twilight was published in 2005 and the film adaptation of this book was released in 2008. However, i would hesitate to call either dracula or twiw an epistolary novel, as there are important differences between these two books and the epistolary novels of the 18th century. Thematically, iwtv covers a breathtaking amount of ground. Vampire fiction gained momentum in 2005 and after when little, brown and company published the young adult supernatural romance twilight, a story where the narrator, bella swan, falls in love with a. The following are noted differences between the original breaking dawn novel and the movie. For my english alevel essay i need to compare two books i have read, so i have decided to do twilight and dracula. Thing is i have no idea how they compare, other than the whole vampire in love thing. Well, i guess if youre like me and are a fan and cant help but notice how relatable it is to so many different monsters.
Laura and carmilla, the vampire, are defined primarily by their physiology rather than by their intelligence or emotions senf 53. They thus directly respond to a tradition of female characters which are but too common in vampire fiction throughout the centuries. Edward and jacob twilight vs dracula untold battles. He only needed blood to keep from going into a mad rage. Still, the differences between them are considerable. Differences between bram stokers dracula book vs movie page 1. Features of the vampires in films contrast and comparison. Feb 03, 2017 in 1898, bram stokers dracula was translated for the first time, into hungarian. Comparing vampires in twilight and bram stokers dracula. In bram stokers, dracula, jonathan harker represents the good, while the vampire, dracula. Dracula has a major role in over 150 films and is referenced in all of the above listed vampire literature. Comparison between dracula by bram stroker and twilight by. Mysterious and feared, yet enticing and seductive, the image of a pale, nearly immortal bloodsucker has endured for centuries.
Paul wilson is an awardwinning, ny times bestselling novelist whose work spans horror, adventure, medical thrillers, science fiction, young adult, and virtually everything between. Van helsing believes that dracula is vlad the impaler, and that he has lived for an impossibly long time after becoming a vampire. I thought he was quite impressive, even dispatching 1,000 men singlehandedly in one night. Since the publication of the first novel of stephenie meyers twilight saga in 2005, millions of readers all over the world, the majority of whom are teenage girls and women, have fallen for the love story of bella and edward. Dracula, novel vs movie essaysbram stokers dracula novel, 1897 compared to bram stokers dracula, 1992 of the many appropriations of dracula.
Though i am not an avid fan of the twilight series, i felt compelled to distinguish the differences between the vampires in each film. And so too are carmilla, interview with the vampire and just about every other story ive read featuring the undead bloodsuckers. Contexts includes probable inspirations for dracula in the earlier works of james malcolm rymer and emily gerard. A rich selection of background and source materials is provided in three areas. Comparing twilight and bram stokers dracula with mtv.
Konrath has sold over three million books worldwide. In dracula, jonathon goes after mina to try and save her in the name of love. Starting in the early 20th, nosferatu was the first vampire film to horrify the masses. Having recently read dracula by bram stoker i decided to watch the film bram stokers dracula to see how close it was to the book. Compare dracula and twilight free essays studymode. In my opinion, neither dracula nor twilight are great books. Bram stokers dracula, 1992 movie directed by frank coppola hasnt deviated as far from the book as many others do. Opera cloaks, sparkles, and prevailing themes since the 19th century, the vampire has been a prevailing literary presence. Jun 04, 2011 looking through the story of dracula, there are many great literary techniques and ideas which stephenie meyer uses in her version of a vampire tale, twilight.
Jan 19, 2010 the twilight series of books and movies has increased the popularity of vampires around the world. It introduced the character of count dracula and established many conventions of subsequent vampire fantasy. This shows the importance that we place on youth in society today. Dracula vs twilight gothic and twilight tyrants evil nature vampires isolated twilight remote monstrous byronic heroes no self respect threat of female sexual expression dracula death horror fragile persecuted maidens villain gothic and dracula dark tyrants taboo immortal byronic. Written in 1897, dracula quickly gained popularity and later became a renowned classic. What are similarities between the twilight movie and the book. While in twilight edward ruthlessly tries to protect bella in the name of love as well. It is pretty faithful to the narrative in the book and even makes reference to the diaries, but there are a number of changes. Though the idea of the vampire has existed since at least the 1700s, it was 1897s dracula, written by bram stoker, which truly thrust the vampire into the realm of popular culture.
Twilight and dracula crossover fanfiction archive with over 8 stories. Though in the olden days they were considered as vicious demons, numerous books and movies have now humanized them, tamed them and gave them feelings. Cullen before, of course, yet i couldnt help but be struck again by his youth, his outrageous. The best stories play on this tension between the fantasy and the monstrosity but i felt in twilight the defanging had gone too far. They missed the scene in the airport and about edwards history. No scene of edward bouncing an apple off his foot exists in the book. Sep 16, 2010 the twilight books make the opposite point, in a way that is very modern in recent literature.
And with twilight, theres the same sexual tension but instead its all about abstinence. Furthered by the release of the movie adaptations of the first three volumes in 2009 and 2010, critics have started to wonder about the foundation of twilight. Comparing twilight and bram stokers dracula with mtvs. Also included are a discussion of stokers working notes for the novel and draculas guest, the original opening chapter to dracula. Dracula as an old man bears some resemblance to vlad the impaler, but no clear parallels are drawn between them. Bella swan, twilights female protagonist, says upon their second meeting, id seen dr. While in twilight it is current, and in pop culture, especially shown in its audience which is mainly teenagers. Looking through the story of dracula, there are many great literary techniques and ideas which stephenie meyer uses in her version of a vampire tale, twilight. Oct 12, 2011 i havent read any of the twilight books, so edward and the gang usually arent the the first ones i think of during class. The twilight saga is about cullens family the family of vampires. I must admit that i have read all five of the stephanie meyer novels only partial of the 5th installment in the series, and of course, bram stokers dracula. Dracula is to vampire novels as a study in scarlet is to detective novels.
Characteristics of the vampire may differ according to authors discretion. Twilight and dracula comparison gothic literature by. John william polidori the vampyre 1819 2 the movie interview with the vampire was directed by neil jordan, starring brad pitt, tom cruise, kirsten dunst, antonio banderas and christian slater. Comparing vampires in twilight and bram stokers dracula kibin. Feb 04, 2014 dracula is to vampire novels as a study in scarlet is to detective novels. Differences between twilight movie and movie 1738 words 7 pages. Edward cullen twilight vampire vampires are some of the most enduring and interesting figures in fiction. The story follows the adventures of the characters who become unwittingly involved with the count and their attempts to defeat him. The theme, this misunderstood thing is not that different me, is prevalent in all sorts of recent science fiction and fantasy a lot of old literature has very distinct good verses evil themes. Feminism and the vampire novel have not traditionally been particularly wellsuited bedfellows. Amy smith says vampires also adapt to the many local differences across the united states.
Vampires are depicted as handsome, charismatic, charming pale human beings that prefer feasting on human blood. He is best known as the author of the keep and creator of the urban mercenary repairman jack. I tried my best to write as dracula would, sorry if his speech sounds incorrect. Dracula vs twilight gothic and twilight tyrants evil nature vampires isolated twilight remote monstrous byronic heroes no self respect threat of female sexual. Hundreds of movie, tv, comic book and video game adaptations followed, most of them not deviating too far from stokers vision. Anne rices books, the vampire chronicles, were the first popular books to show vampires in a more human light. The twilight series of books and movies has increased the popularity of vampires around the world. Dracula by otto binder abebooks abebooks shop for books. Recently i have read dracula, and found it to be an amazing book, by far the best vampire novel of eternity.
Between 1879 and 1898, stoker was a business manager for the lyceum theatre in london, where he supplemented his income by writing many sensational novels, his most successful being the vampire tale dracula published on 26 may 1897. I began to wonder what would happen if they were to meet, hence this story. Dracula vs twilight bram stokers dracula 1897 is a gothic horror novel about the transylvanian vampire count dracula and his attempted migration to london. Ctrl acmd a will select all, or use the tweet or tumblr links to share the work on your twitter or tumblr account. Those are minor differences in comparison to the fromhorrortoromance switch that coppola gave to his movie. The 1970 franco one was faithful as for the characterisation of dracula and as for the jonathan harkers stay at draculas, but i think it differs much from the book thereafter. Edward bounces an apple off his foot in the cafeteria scene in the movie and catches it in the same manner as is seen on the twilight book cover. Dracula needed blood to stay young were as edward was permanently young.
Movie and book comparison in most successful novels, what tends to follow is typically a movie or a tv show based on it. Draculathe woman in white books compared librarything. A comparison of the vampire novels dracula by bram stoker. The complete guide to vampire mythology by montague, charlotte from amazons fiction books store. Near fine paperback copy of dracula in comic book form by alden mcwilliams text by otto binder and craig tennis. Difference between dracula and vampire difference between. Nov 01, 2007 hey guys, i need to write an indepth essay on the similiarites and differences of bram stokers novel dracula and the 1992 film version of it. Even if they preach abstinence, her books are as much about the beast with two backs as the one that sucks you dry of blood. It seems so difficult to get away from twilight in this class.
He doesnt show her his skin in the sun in some little patch of sun but in a meadow. Just a couple of years later, it was published in icelandic. Apr 27, 2012 the best stories play on this tension between the fantasy and the monstrosity but i felt in twilight the defanging had gone too far. Just dot down any info you have on this, thanks hopz, nov 1, 2007. And they dont fly out of the window after he show him his room. Find books like dracula from the worlds largest community of readers. Differences between twilight book and movie 818 words. The character has the same name in both the book and the movie. Twilight book to movie differences twilight saga wiki. Jan 06, 2009 having recently read dracula by bram stoker i decided to watch the film bram stokers dracula to see how close it was to the book. Whats the difference between dracula the book and bram. From the award winning twilight series to tv shows such as true blood, vampires have become a nationwide phenomenon, but how do they compare to bram stokers dracula. Setting in dracula there is a historical victorian setting, and is much more relevant to gothic literature than twilight is. From dracula to twilight, vampires evolve with the times.
Everyday low prices on a huge range of new releases and classic fiction. She becomes close friends with a young man who loves her. Well in the book edward tells bella hes a vampire in the car not in the woods. Though the idea of the vampire has existed since at least the 1700s, it was 1897s. However, the book isnt necessarily a manuscript for the film. Still, it sounds like they do compare pretty well to many of the topics we talk about, especially with the parts of dracula you pointed out. Honestly, the book started to feel like one long mantra. Vampires and dracula are undead creatures that suck the blood of humans. Hey guys, i need to write an indepth essay on the similiarites and differences of bram stokers novel dracula and the 1992 film version of it. Edward wont have sex or turn bella until they are married. Epistolary novels consisted mostly of letters, while d and twiw consist mostly of.
While in twilight there are again both and good vampires. Oct 15, 2011 dracula needed blood to stay young were as edward was permanently young. So there are major differences between the two vampires and this makes sense because the books were written a hundred and fifty years apart. Its release date was december 1st, 1994 in germany. Dracula was very cool, and made edward look pathetic. Come in to read stories and fanfics that span multiple fandoms in the twilight and dracula universe.
The twilight saga by stephenie meyer the twilight saga consists of 4 parts. So far in dracula, i just couldnt help but notice some very extreme similarities and differences between these. In 1898, bram stokers dracula was translated for the first time, into hungarian. Difference between dracula and vampire dracula vs vampire. Preserving love both novels have the element of love, and preserving it. While meyer uses the cullen clan as a group of good vampires, there are still elements of the vampires that prey on innocent humans, much like count dracula. Batman beating the joker, spiderman banishing the green goblin, and arthur and the guys defeating dracula are all examples of literature based on the theme good vs. Twilight new moon eclipse breaking dawn part 1 breaking dawn part 2. The novel tells the story of draculas attempt to move from transylvania to england so that he may find new blood and spread the undead curse, and of the battle between dracula and a small group of. Copy and paste the following code to link back to this work ctrl acmd a will select all, or use the tweet or tumblr links to share the work on your twitter or tumblr account. Jul 12, 2011 thematically, iwtv covers a breathtaking amount of ground. Dracula is an 1897 gothic horror novel by irish author bram stoker.
1434 1395 775 927 1425 1613 1205 264 1625 1373 1562 756 282 9 404 824 1359 1429 856 538 46 1644 621 1006 1257 699 1550 475 873 1481 1520 403 660 1079 980 85 778 1123 123 318 530 432 1403 5